Blog
Posts for category: Opinion
-
From Medieval Guilds to AI: How Guild Knowledge is Becoming the Missing Piece for Modern Learning
Walk into a medieval guildhall and a modern AI lab and, on the surface, they could not be more different. One smells of timber, leather and metal; the other of coffee and electronics. Yet both are wrestling with the same underlying question: how does a community grow and protect its shared sense of what “good” looks like – and keep that sense of quality alive when everything around it is changing?
-
For 500 years, Guilds were how expertise worked. Then we forgot. Now we're remembering.
The craft guilds of medieval Europe such as goldsmiths, weavers, stonemasons and apothecaries are often remembered as protectionist trade associations. That reputation is not entirely undeserved. But it obscures something more important: they were the most sophisticated knowledge transmission institutions the pre-modern world produced.
-
VAR, Kayfabe and Why Assessment can Feel Fake
Rick Rubin once said that professional wrestling is “real” and everything else is fake. Wrestling is honest about its kayfabe – the shared pretence that what you’re watching is a contest, even though everyone involved knows it’s scripted. The fiction is part of the product.
-
When the Black Box Gets Good
For a long time, the debate about AI in assessment focused on capability. Could AI produce judgements that were reliable enough to take seriously? Could it handle open-ended responses, complex performances, or evidence of learning that did not fit neatly into a mark scheme?
-
Newsletter May 2026
RM Compare launches a new era of on-demand Comparative Judgement. There has never been a more uncertain time in education. There has never been a more exciting time to be in education.
-
Lessons from Software Engineering: Why AI in Assessment May Be Solving the Wrong Problem
Every few years, a body of evidence emerges from an unexpected direction that turns out to be exactly what education needed to hear. We think this might be one of those moments.
-
AI Assessment has a dignity problem - here's how to fix it
AI assessment has a dignity problem. Not a technology problem, or even just a fairness problem, but a problem with how it treats people at precisely the moments they are most exposed and most human.
-
Gradually then suddenly (Part 4 / 4)
If the first post in this series traced the industrial birth of marking, the second described the temptation to use AI as a faster horse, and the third argued for rediscovering human judgement, this final post asks the practical question: what would assessment look like if it were designed for the world now emerging rather than the one that produced marks and grades?
-
Rediscovering Human Judgement in an Age of AI (Part 3 / 4)
If the first post argued that marking is a child of the Industrial Revolution, and the second showed how AI is mostly being used to build faster horses, this third post is about something older and more fundamental: human judgement itself.